CPIM Disowns Mayawati Tag, Turnaround Once Again
Palash Biswas
The CPI(M) has said it does not look at in terms of projecting an individual for the prime minister’s post, an indication that it was not keen on seeing BSP chief Mayawati in the top post.CPM general secretary Prakash Karat on Thursday made it clear that BSP chief Mayawati was not his party’s choice as PM candidate. He firmly ruled out any post-poll alliance with the UPA.CPM leader stood defiant. He said there is no question of a post-poll tie up with the UPA. He also said that he will support the UNPA in fighting issues like price rise, inflation and the nuclear deal, but will not consider it as a third front. Communist Party of India General Secretary Prakash Karat on Thursday refused any possibility of any party alliance with the United Progressive Alliance even after general elections due next year.
Whether or not the UPA wins the trust vote on July 22, the CPM feels the government’s collapse is only a matter of time.
What a Turnaround!With the Left failing to stop the government from going to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and the government winning the trust vote, many Congress leaders had not ruled out an alliance with the Left in the upcoming general elections. And I tell you, the opportunist Marxists may repeat History anytime.
A clever leader like Amar Singh , the master of Horse Trading, landed in Kolkat just yesterday and addressed a press conference with Fire Brand Brahman Leader Ms Mamata. Amar Singh fielded Mamamta against Mayawati. Though a tough bargainer like Amara did not miss to mention that his hear only lies with Sister Mamata but the Mind still remains with the Left!
It is a clear indication of dangers ahead for the Left, a steep decay in High caste vote bank. While the Left is no more that sure about SC, OBC and Muslim Votes in Kearla and Bengal. Tripura has a different demography and the Tripura Marxists have enough causes for enthusiasm for Mayawati!
Only on 25th July, late after midnight I was talking face to face the Marxist Minister in Tripura. The Poet politician, Anil Sarkar claimed that it was a masterstroke and we must welcome the latest Party Line . I explained how I never believed that CPIM could hold this line very longer. I never expected the Marxist turnaround so soon. Anilda has been insisting that Dalit Liberation is only possible with a Marxist line on Ambedkar and Rabindra Nath Tagore. Thus, he runs all the missions on Ambedkar`s name. now, he has launched a Matribhasha Mission campaign all along the North East on a Tagore line of Nationality!
Speaking on the alliances prior to the trust vote in Lok Sabha on July 22, 2008, Karat said, “Mayawati left alliance with the UPA before the Left parties withdrew support to the UPA. Now, we go by what the parties say. They have come out against the nuclear deal and said they would work against the UPA government. It is only after we withdrew support, we said we would contact all the secular parties who are opposed to the nuclear deal and who can stand in vote against the UPA government. As part of that process, I met Mayawati, Deve Gowda, Ajit Singh, leaders of TDP and the UNPA, and then came to a common understanding.”
“He (CPI General Secretary A B Bardhan) was asked, do you think she can become PM. He said, Yes why not. That is his way of saying that he has no objection to any particular leader becoming PM. We don’t look at in terms of projecting an individual,” CPI(M) General Secretary Prakash Karat clarified in Thiruvananthapuram.
Asked if he was saying that Mayawati would not be projected as Prime Minister, he told Malayalam channel “Kairali TV” he said he was not ready to say anything as “it is too premature”.
On 26th evening, I was debating with some Marxist Senior comrades in Mohan Singh Palace Coffee house. The Marxist comrades defended the party line and claimed that the communists in India, never deviated from Ideology!
The Marichjhanpi film was to be screened in JNU by Delhi friends and was withheld. It could not be screened.
kolakata High Caste hatred is documented quite Human in Bangla Ntionality and literary disguise. Tara shankar and Sharat Chandra, Sunil Gango, Ateen Bando and Debesh Roy are best examples.It swallowed the Marichjhanpi episode.
And his Hero falls miserably!
“Be very clear. I didn’t use the word Third Alternative. I have not not talked about the Third Alternative. I have not not talked about the Third Alternative….Our party’s understanding of the Third Alternative is not some combination to fight elections. The Third Alternative has to be in terms of policies and programmes,” he said.
To a question on supporting Congress after the elections for forming a government, Karat said “we are going to call the defeat of BJP and the Congress. And after that if we support the Congress, I don’t know, I think people accuse us of opportunism. So why do you think that there can be only either a BJP-led government or a Congress-led government.”
Karat said even when the Left supported the government they knew the Congress was wedded to liberalisation policies. But the Left could check privatisation in some sectors while it could not not tolerate serious deviation from the common minimum programme on an issue like the strategic alliance with the US.
To a question whether it was a mistake to have supported the Congress, he said “we made a mistake in believing the commitment of the top leadership of the country including the prime minister. We have to see whether we can put faith in the Congress leadership again.”
On the charge that the CPI(M) had once dubbed the BSP as a casteist formation, Karat said all parties except the Left had played the caste card.
“But the assertion of dalit forces is a democratic and an awakening aspect which we must recognise.”
Asked why he had always refrained from making critical comments against Congress President Sonia Gandhi, he said they had always criticised the Congress leadership as well as the prime minister.
“Prime Minister, of course is running the government. Leadership cannot be reduced to one individual and is collective.”
Karat Thursday indicated it was a mistake to have trusted the Congress leadership and said that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh does not “understand how the Communist party functions”. Apparently regretting the legislative support the CPI-M-led Left parties extended to the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government, Karat declared that there would not be any ties with the Congress in future.
In an interview telecast on Malayalam channel Kairali TV, Karat said both the Congress leadership and the prime minister had assured the Left that they would not go ahead with the India-US civil nuclear deal even if they were allowed to carry forward negotiations on an India specific safeguards agreement with the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
“Because they said they will talk and come back… if you object we will not proceed further. Now when the prime minister, the Congress president (Sonia Gandhi) and the Congress leadership give such an assurance, we thought yes, let them go, talk and come back. They are bringing this to the (UPA-Left nuclear) committee. When we object in the committee, they will not proceed. This is the assurance they gave us in November.”
He added that the meeting in which the assurance was given was also attended by External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee.
Asked if the CPI-M had overestimated the trustworthiness of the Congress party he said: “It seems like that.”
Reacting to Manmohan Singh’s remarks that the CPI-M general secretary has “miscalculated” the developments, Karat said: “The bourgeois party leaders look at their (party) practices in which the leader decides everything. They do not understand how the Communist party functions.”
He said emphatically that the Left would continue to combat the government in parliament.
“We are not parties like the DMK, RJD or the NCP. They are part of the UPA along with the Congress party. We cannot have any understanding or alliance with the Congress party… we are in no way bound to support the Congress-led coalition. We will work with all the non-Congress secular parties – the non Congress secular parties who are today not with the BJP or the Congress.”
The CPI-M led Left parties – that withdrew support to the Manmohan Singh government over the India-US civil nuclear deal – have not yet taken a decision on who they would support as a prime ministerial candidate of the non-BJP, non-Congress front, he added.
“We have not decided yet,” Karat said when asked if Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mayawati was their candidate for the top post.
Karat said the Left would enter into an electoral alliance, though he did not want it to be named the ‘third front’.
“I never talked about third alternative. Our party’s understanding of the third alternative is not some combination to fight elections. The third alternative should be in terms of policies and programmes. We don’t consider the UNPA as the third alternative. We told them that this is the alternative we were thinking about.”
On joining hands with Mayawati, a move that had been widely criticised, he said: “Mayawati left the alliance with the UPA before the Left parties withdrew support to it. She had come out of the nuclear deal before we even talked to her. Now, we go by what the parties say. They have come out against the nuclear deal, and said they would work against the UPA government. It is only after we withdrew support that we said we would contact all the secular parties opposed to the nuclear deal and who can stand against the UPA government. As part of that process, I met Mayawati, Deve Gowda, Ajit Singh, leaders of TDP and the UNPA, and then came to a common understanding.”
Predicting that the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) government, which won the July 22 trust vote in the Lok Sabha, would face “many roadblocks” in parliament, Karat said the Left would continue to combat the government in both houses.
He pointed out that the government did not have a majority in the upper house and would face troubles in the Lok Sabha – where the Left has 59 MPs – when it came to the passage of financial bills.
“We would like to use (such occasions) effectively to combat the government,” he told the channel.
Chautala’s INLD rejects Mayawati as PM candidate
“No to the proposal of her as PM,” INLD general secretary Ajay Chautala told reporters here yesterday on a question whether INLD could join hands with BSP and project Mayawati as the future prime minister.
Chautala, however was not adverse to forge a pre-poll alliance with BSP during elections in the states.
INLD was contemplating pre-poll alliance with any of the UNPA members and would field over 100 candidates in the polls, he said.
PTI Slamming BSP supremo Mayawati for demanding a probe into the assets of all ex-Prime Ministers, the Uttar Pradesh Congress on Wednesday said this showed …
![]() Sahara Samay |
Mulayam threatens to demolish all Maya statues
Indian Express, India - 30 Jul 2008 If we come to power, all statues of Mayawati will be demolished,” SP chief Mulayam Singh Yadav said. While the allies of the Congress have been given … SP demands committee to probe Mayawati’s assets Howrah News Service Mulayam does not want ministerial berth Thaindian.com Amar stands by Mamata Times of India Expressindia.com - Zee News all 51 news articles » |
|
Left fuels Mayawati’s PM ambitions
Merinews, India - 10 hours ago While Mayawati has taken over the leadship of the Third Front, Speaker Somnath Chatterjee future remains a mystery.. AFTER HAVING failed to topple the … |
![]() Thaindian.com |
Be ready for coalitions, Mayawati tells BSP
Economic Times, India - 27 Jul 2008 LUCKNOW: Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mayawati Sunday told party MPs and ministers about the importance and usefulness of coalition governments, … Mayawati plans big, may enter into alliance for ‘welfare’ of … Expressindia.com Mayawati returns to Lucknow with renewed hope Hindustan Times Mayawati calls meet, aware BSP leaders from Cong, BJP MyNews.in Zee News - Outlook (subscription) all 63 news articles » |
|
If Maya can rule UP, why can’t she rule the country: Gowda
Times of India, India - 3 hours ago NEW DELHI: JD(S) chief HD Deve Gowda has said that he is not against BSP chief Mayawati becoming the prime minister. “She is the Chief Minister of the … |
“The UNPA will emerge as a ‘third force’ in the country and attempts were being made to evolve the alliance in the four states — Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Chattisgarh and Delhi, going to polls later this year” Chautala said.
He also said Rajasthan should have a farmer as its next Chief Minister.
| Sorted by relevance Sort by date Sort by date with duplicates included |
|
New! Get the latest news on Mayawati with Google Alerts.
Searches related to: Mayawati
| uttar pradesh | bahujan samaj party | mulayam singh yadav |
| samajwadi party | chief minister | dalit |
CJ: Bhagat , 5 hours ago Views:52 Comments:0
|
Be ready for coalitions, Mayawati tells BSP
LUCKNOW: Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mayawati Sunday told party MPs and ministers about the importance and usefulness of coalition governments, party sources said.
Mayawati said the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) should be ready to accept a pre-poll alliance taking into account the fast changing scenario in national politics, the sources added. The chief minister also called upon party activists to convince Muslims about the correctness of BSP’s stand over the India-US nuclear deal. “We need to inform Muslims that by opposing the nuclear deal, we supported them and protected their rights,” a party leader said. Mayawati also directed district coordinators of BSP to bring active members of their respective regions to the party’s national convention to be organised here Aug 9. The BSP played a key role in the opposition’s attempts to vote out Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s Congress-led government in a trust vote over the nuclear deal. The government won the motion. |
WA today |
Ajoy Bose, the author of Behenji, a political biography of …
Rediff, India - 22 Jul 2008 Mayawati has changed the political scenario. Her game plan is very simple. There are several issues on which she stands to gain. … Turning politics upside down Sydney Morning Herald Delhi bound: ‘untouchable’ woman flying high in India The Age ‘Half of India doesn’t vote for either Congress or BJP’ Expressindia.com Monsters and Critics.com - Sydney Morning Herald all 289 news articles » |
|
Mayawati, Left, regional parties to hold nationwide stir
Economic Times, India - 23 Jul 2008 In the high-voltage political drama leading up to the trust vote, Mayawati has been the rallying point for the opposition parties including the smaller … Mayawati a pivot for Third Front NDTV.com Ousting govt only agenda: Mayawati Times of India SP MPs wary of Mayawati resurgence The Statesman Expressindia.com - Hindustan Times all 206 news articles » |
|
Cong leaders held near Maya’s village
The Statesman, India - 21 hours ago “This is proof of the Mayawati government’s tyranny. We were simply going to Badalpur to express our solidarity with those farmers who have lost their land … |
![]() IBNLive.com |
Mayawati mum, but ambition clear
Economic Times, India - 24 Jul 2008 LUCKNOW: The leadership issue of the new “Third Front” still hangs in balance with even the BSP chief Mayawati, who has become the pivot around which the … The Mayawati matrix Daily News & Analysis Maya gets ready for Third Front Times of India UNPA, BSP, Left parties to vote against UPA govt Press Trust of India Howrah News Service - Press Trust of India all 58 news articles » |
|
Mualayam threatens to raze Maya statues if voted back to power
Hindustan Times, India - 30 Jul 2008 “We will follow the way shown by Mayawati and bulldoze all her statues if she did not mend her ways. I will press 50-60 bulldozers at a time and remove all … |
|
Indian politician angers locals
guardian.co.uk, UK - 19 hours ago She may be a former schoolteacher from a poor untouchable family but Kumari Mayawati, India’s Dalit queen and prime minister-in-waiting, wants people to … |
![]() NDTV.com |
Boom in Mayawati futures
Economic Times, India - 21 Jul 2008 Mayawati has gone from strength to strength in the last two years, and looks poised to win anything from 40 to 60 seats in the next election. … Why did Gowda side with Mayawati? Ask the stars (Political Prattle) Thaindian.com JD-S with Mayawati, to vote against UPA MyNews.in Deve Gowda moves closer to Mayawati Newstrack India Hindu - Thaindian.com all 188 news articles » |
![]() Times Now.tv |
UPA, NDA conspiring to prevent me from becoming PM: Mayawati
Economic Times, India - 22 Jul 2008 22 Jul, 2008, 2305 hrs IST, PTI NEW DELHI: Undeterred by the outcome of the trust vote, BSP chief Mayawati on Tuesday alleged the UPA and as well as the NDA … Mayawati goes all out to poach on SP MPs Times of India No chain reaction Arab News Mayawati to activate Third Front attack on UPA Fresh News Hindustan Times - Economic Times all 120 news articles » |
![]() Moneycontrol.com |
Post trust vote: Experts take on road ahead for UPA
Moneycontrol.com, India - 24 Jul 2008 Q: The relationship between the Left and the Congress is one aspect that is intriguing tonight, the other is the relationship between the BJP and Mayawati. … |
Filed under: Uncategorized











